Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Liam Sharp's avatar

Sorry it's been a brutal year, Grant. I know how much those cats are a part of your life. We left ours with friends in the US when we moved because of logistics, but he's getting shipped back to us early next year. I have no idea what the local moggies will make of our 'murican rescue! He's going to miss the wide open spaces afforded to him in CA, trading it for a Victorian terrace and busy roads. Just hoping that future doesn't prove brutal for us - and him - too! Much love. x

Patrick Gerard's avatar

I didn't think there was a beef with Ostrander. If anything, responding to his bit of fun with The Writer here in the comics event of 2025 struck me as surprisingly reverent! You're acknowledging a 30 year old lark from a fairly dense part of comics lore in the middle of a pop track!

That's something I've missed about your comics, I suppose. That feeling that every little thing counts in some way because you're just reporting it.

I remember back when Waid's Birthright hit that the main Super-books were scrambling for how to incorporate it as the new origin and, being "solicited" (mainly for backups in Austen's Action that were solicited then cancelled), I was getting extremely contradictory advice, with Loeb telling me I had to pitch for Superman himself and maybe Tom Palmer telling me to focus on lesser knowns.

DiDio actually commented on that batch of pitches, thanking me for the hit list. Made me a bit anxious as I had a focus on buddy stories with one being Jay Garrick and Alan Scott stranded on a cruise with Blue Beetle and Booster Gold as Amazo scrambles their powers and gadgets. I did NOT want to contribute to the deaths of Alan or Jay -- and I would later learn my role in Earth-2 Superman's demise. That's really my hunting limit for the season.

Anyway, they were trying to incorporate Birthright midstream in a soft reboot launched by Return to Krypton that was meant to marry the Silver Age Krypton with Byrne era folksiness. I gather Jennette Khan had signed off on that and it was axed as soon as she was out.

And I had two ways to do that in a single issue. One was an epic mini-crisis that would have united Bibbo Bibbowski, the Alpha Centurion, Halk Kar, Mon-El, the Hyperfamily of Trom, in a story where dastardly forces from the Council of Brainiacs rewrite history to keep Lois from getting pregnant.

But the other and my preferred of the two was for Superman himself to venture across Hypertime and arrive at our world to give an interview where he explains both why he doesn't show up here to help and intervene and proceeds to go through a stack of old comics up through the current ones to explain that we'd been getting details of his life wrong with unnecessary retcons. His continuity had never been reset! He never forgot the first Crisis! Everyone kept misinterpreting the time period he lives in as whatever their time period was when they were tuning into his universe.

He would then draw reference of the Birthright Jor-El and Lara and sum up how his history was less complicated than we keep making it!

It was on the whole a breezy affair with a number of classic beats such as taking the reporter flying.

With the last page twist that the man we'd just been seeing was Ultraman. "The idiots bought it all!" He'd announce. "Obviously the best lies have considerable truth to them. But everything has been set in motion. No one even noticed what I was doing while I was there."

And with that, the history gets updated going forward with the double reveal that all comics up until then had unreliable narration of real events... and the guy who just set the record straight is ALSO a liar.

10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?